Explore Khalvontawi — a digital bridge between forest roots and modern voices from Northeast India, featuring news, culture, and justice.
Friday, August 2, 2013
Mâtu (Madu), a modest Dai Village
ZYA GHQ Gen Secy Lunpi Hatzaw Delhi ah mualliam
Delhi ah ZYA Gen Secy mualliam
Thursday, August 1, 2013
SHO Calls NE Students in Vasant Vihar Police Station
NE Girl Thrown Out by Landlord in Munirka, Now DCP South Wants to Meet NE Students
New Delhi, Aug 01, 2013: A meeting with SHO Vasant Vihar Police Station, Anil Sharma, was held on Wednesday evening in Vasant Vihar PS, South Delhi, attended by Northeast students. The meeting discussed the steps taken by Delhi Police to ensure the safety and security of NE people in Delhi. The SHO also assured the safety of BPO employees, especially NE women residing in Munirka. He stated that the police had started night patrols in Munirka.
Dr. Alana Golmei, founding member and General Secretary of the North East Support Centre & Helpline (NESCH) Delhi, and its media incharge, Bruce K. Thangkhal, also attended the meeting. Dr. Golmei stressed the need for prompt action from the police and called for stricter measures against any lawbreakers. Representatives from the NE student community also shared the challenges faced by NE people. The meeting ended on a positive note. However, the problems persist—the same night proved it.
A 23-year-old girl from Nagaland, who lives with her brother and sister-in-law in Munirka, was allegedly thrown out of her room by the landlord, Dariyao Singh Tokas, and his two sons, Prashant and Rohit, around 9 PM. Many of her belongings were damaged by the landlord and his sons, the victim told our correspondent.
The
victim had been renting a room in Munirka’s House No. 118-A, owned by Dariyao
Singh Tokas, since December last year. “My brother paid the electricity bill of Rs 1,108 on Tuesday evening. Soon after, our landlord locked our room and told my
brother, his wife, and their eight-month-old child to leave. When I reached
home around 9 PM, the landlord and his two sons began throwing out all our
belongings. I begged them to wait just five minutes to vacate the room, but
they refused to listen and abused us,” she said.
The victim, who works in a spa, stated that her landlord and his sons were ferociously damaging many of her belongings as they threw them outside the room.
A
case has been registered at Vasant Vihar Police Station under sections
448/427/34 of the IPC on the same night. “The culprits will be booked and
punished according to the law,” said SHO Anil Sharma.
“Most
of our problems arise from Munirka. The landlords and local people must
understand our culture, food habits, and way of living, just as we understand
theirs. There is no sense of brotherhood or love in the minds of these people.
That is the biggest problem,” said Huten Alexander, General Secretary of the
Naga Students’ Union Delhi (NSUD), who assisted the victim.
Munirka,
one of the most densely populated localities in the national capital, is home
to many Northeast students, government employees, workers, musicians, and
professionals. Munirka frequently makes headlines for the wrong reasons. “Most
of the locals and landlords here in Munirka are impolite and abusive towards NE
residents,” said John, a Munirka resident and BA student at Motilal Nehru
College.
It may be noted that Delhi Police has often failed to curb crimes against women in the national capital. Earlier in April this year, the force drew the ire of UPA Chairperson Sonia Gandhi and Home Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde. Both reprimanded Delhi Police for failing to curb crimes against women. Under public pressure, two top police officers were removed from their positions. Sources indicate that DCP South Delhi, Chhaya Sharma, was transferred to Mizoram in the wake of the gruesome Delhi gang rape incident, which sparked massive nationwide protests. DCP Prabhakar was reassigned to the Prime Minister’s security contingent following the recent rape and brutalization of a five-year-old girl in Gandhi Nagar, East Delhi. Additional CP Sanjeev Kumar was also transferred to the PM’s security. BS Jaiswal replaced Sharma as DCP South, while Ajay Kumar took over as DCP East.
Now, DCP South BS Jaiswal has called upon NE students for a meeting at Hauz Khas Police Station on August 3. Delhi Police has been initiating various measures to ensure the safety of Northeast people, a police officer said.
~ Bruce K. Thangkhal
(Special Correspondent, The Mizoram Post, Manipur Chronicle, Zogam Today)
Demand for a Separate Time Zone for Northeast India
New Delhi, Jul 31 : Once at loggerheads, the Assam Congress and the United Liberation Front of Asom (ULFA) have both come together for demand of a separate time zone for the northeast region.There is an annual loss of at least Rs. 94,900 crore in the region because of redundant power consumption, according to calculations by noted filmmaker and former ISRO scientist, Jahnu Barua.
While the demand is a key point in ULFA’s ongoing talks with the government, a team of MLAs from Assam on July 25 has submitted a memorandum to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh seeking a separate time zone for the seven states.
“We will now approach the political leadership of all the other NE states to press for a separate time zone,” said Debabrata Saikia, MLA and son of former Assam CM Hiteshwar Saikia.
While it is being articulated in political circles now, a separate time zone has been a long-standing demand of eminent personalities hailing from the region.
The east-west spread of India extends across 28 longitudes accounting for about two hours as a result of which the sun rises two hours earlier in the extreme eastern part of the country than the western tip.
The Union home ministry had proposed a separate time zone for the region in 2009-10. Former home secretary GK Pillay had told HT: “We have to change our mindset. The demand for a separate time zone for the northeast is a valid one and I hope it is granted. There is a lot to be gained from it”.
Source: sinlung.com
JNU student girl still critical in Delhi
DCP South wants to meet NE Students
An FIR u/s 448/427/34 IPC was registered in Vasant Vihar PS the same night with the assistance of Mr Huten Alexander, general secretary, Naga Students' Union Delhi (NSUD) and Mr Bruce K. Thangkhal, journalist & media incharge, NE Helpline Delhi.
Mr Anil Sharma, SHO, Vasant Vihar PS told NE HELPLINE this morning that the culprits will be booked and will be punished according to the law.
Again, there will be another important meeting with DCP South on 03rd August, 2013 (Saturday), 4pm at DCP Office, Hauz Khas. Delhi Police has initiated various steps for the safety of the Northeast people.
It will be an opportunity to address the issues and problems face by the NE people. All NE students/community/church leaders are kindly invited to attend the meeting. Your kind presence will speak volume to the Delhi Police.
In Public Interest,
North East Helpline Delhi
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Northeast Community Meets SHO Vasant Vihar, Delhi | NESCH Initiative
On July 31, 2013, members of the Northeast community living in the capital, led by the Northeast Support Centre & Helpline (NESCH), held a meeting with Mr. Anil Sharma, Station House Officer (SHO) of Vasant Vihar Police Station, South Delhi.
The meeting aimed to address key concerns of the Northeast community and strengthen communication and cooperation with local law enforcement.
by Mr. Bruce K. Thangkhal, Media In-Charge, Northeast Support Centre & Helpline.
Girl student attacked in JNU campus with axe, attacker dies
The incident took place today morning around 11 am at the JNU campus where Akash and Roshni were studying Korean language in the university's linguistic department.
The attack took place in room number 203 of the university after both the students reportedly entered into an argument.
After attacking the girl, the accused reportedly tried to commit suicide by slitting his throat and consuming pesticide.
The attacker was admitted to the AIIMS hospital where he succumbed to his injuries. Meanwhile, the victim has been admitted to Safdurjung hospital and her condition is stated to be critical.
The cause of the attack is still not clear as the victim is still critical and not in a condition to give a statement.
A country made pistol was also recovered by the police from the spot.
Bassi to head Delhi Police as Commissioner of Police today

The new commissioner will take charge at 1 p.m., a police official said.
A 1977 batch IPS officer of the Arunachal Pradesh-Goa-Mizoram-Union Territories (AGMUT) cadre, Bassi, 57, was the front-runner for the post.
Currently special commissioner of police (administration), he previously headed the Delhi Traffic Police and was also Goa's director general of police.
Bassi has also been the special commissioner (vigilance), joint commissioner (southern range) and additional commissioner (northern range).
Neeraj Kumar, a 1976 batch IPS officer, took charge of Delhi Police from B.K. Gupta July 1 last year. His tenure saw the brutal Dec 16, 2012 gang-rape of a young woman, which unleashed unprecedented mass protests in the capital. The woman died while under treatment in Singapore Dec 29.
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
Koite gei ah Shaktiman accident
Lia Rosie Simt ein BSc Physics ah Topper
Tutung Manipur University result suo ah Lia Rosie Lamthiankim Simte (23) d/o Pu H. Donghao & Pi Niangzaching, Bible Hill Rengkai in BSc Physics Honours ah Topper (Rank 1) in pang. Unau pasal 1 leh numei 2 lah ah amilai ahi. Blue Star Academy apat Class X (2008) leh Rayburn College apat Class XII (2010) first division tuohin ana zou hi. MU ah M.Sc sutzop sawm a, PhD (Doctorate) zaw chia Professor (sangsia) a pan a ut thu gen hi. Zogam Today in kipahpih mama mai, alungtup muolsuo hing di’n a deisah thu tami tungtawn in puong hi.
Pic: simtepeople.com
700 trucks carrying essentials enter Manipur
The flow of commodities in landlocked Manipur along the Imphal-Dimapur highway, its key supply route, has stopped owing to a massive landside near Kohima 17 days ago, triggering sudden inflation even as BJP leader LK Advani urged Union home minister Sushil Kumar Shinde to resolve the crisis urgently.
The price of one litre of petrol has soared to Rs 150 in the grey market and Rs 90 for a litre of diesel. People were seen standing in long queues at certain outlets where the sale of fuel has been started under the government's supervision.
Prices of onion, potato, pulses, baby food and certain household items also jumped up considerably in the open market. Of the 700 trucks that entered Manipur with security escorts, 16 carried medicine, 30 urea, 2 carried filled oxygen cylinders, 20 SK oil and 26 each carried LPG and petrol. Others were laden with baby food and other food items, sources said.
A leader of All Manipur Road Transport Drivers and Motor Workers' Union said the trucks are expected to reach Imphal on Tuesday morning.
Union minister of state for defence Jitendra Singh assured to upgrade the 221-Km Imphal-Jiribam stretch to an "all-weather road" at the earliest.
Source:indiatimes.com
Ashwini Kumar sworn-in as Manipur governor
Imphal: Ashwini Kumar, the Governor of Nagaland, has been given the additional charge of Manipur after the former incumbent Gurbachan Jagat ended his tenure last week, official sources said.Mr Kumar, who arrived in Imphal on Sunday from Kohima by road, was administered the oath of office by Chief Justice of Manipur High Court A M Sapre at a simple function held at the Raj Bhavan, the sources said.
The post of Manipur Governor fell vacant following the completion of tenure of Mr Jagat who left for his home state Punjab on July 24.Source: ndtv.com
Brief profile :
Dr. Ashwani Kumar, the former Director of Central Bureau of Investigation and Director General of Himachal Pradesh police served Government of India and the Government of Himachal Pradesh with utmost distinction, dedication and devotion for more than 37 years.
Dr. Ashwani Kumar was born on 15th November 1950 and belongs to Nahan, District Sirmour of Himachal Pradesh.
Dr. Ashwani Kumar is a visiting faculty to many Universities, colleges and Institutions.
Dr. Ashwani Kumar joined the Indian Police Service in 1973 and was allotted to the Himachal Pradesh cadre.
PRICE OF INDIGENEITY: Meiteis’ demand for Scheduled Tribe Status(Republished from kanglaonline)
Seram Neken, Imphal based Freelance Journalist
Simply speaking, groups with indigenous character are termed as ‘Scheduled Tribes’ in India. The word ‘Indigenous’ as used by the international community, is not used in Indian constitution as it refers to some sense of political self-determination. Perhaps, the framers of the Constitution gave room for cultural self-determinism of some specific groups in the form of Scheduled Tribe and Scheduled Caste under Clause 1 of Articles 341 and 342. Besides their primitive nature and geographical isolation; the Scheduled Tribes are identified with their social, educational and economic backwardness. Taking into account the presumed sufferings from extreme backwardness on account of the primitive agricultural practices, lack of infrastructural facilities and geographical isolation, the Constitution made provisions for safeguarding the interests and for accelerating the socio-economic development of the scheduled communities.
Indigenous peoples are peoples defined in international or national legislation as having a set of specific rights based on their historical ties to a particular territory, and their cultural or historical distinctiveness from other politically and socially dominant populations. They are determined to preserve, develop and transmit to future generations their ancestral territories, identity, cultural patterns, social institutions and legal systems. A special set of political rights for the indigenous peoples have been set by international organizations like the United Nations, the International Labour Organization and the World Bank in accordance international law. The United Nations have issued a Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples to guide national policies of various countries to collective rights of indigenous peoples—such as culture, identity, language and access to employment, health, education and natural resources. India has the most substantial population of indigenous communities which are recognized as Scheduled Tribes in its Constitution. In Himachal Pradesh, Rajputs and Brahmans are schedule Tribes. In Tripura, the descendents of the Kings are scheduled tribes. In Sikkim, the Bhutias are scheduled Tribes, so on and so forth.
Numerous government policies aim at promotion of tribal communities inhabiting all over India. The central and state governments have made sustained efforts to provide opportunities to these communities for their economic development by eradicating poverty and health problems and developing communication for removal of isolation of their habitats. Although Article 14 provides for equality before law and equal protection of law to all people, Article 15(4) allows the States to make special provisions for the advancement of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. In matters of employment or appointment to any office, Article 16(4) mentions that the State should make provisions for reservation in favour of any backward class citizen who is not adequately represented in the services. Article 16 (4A) and 16(4B) empower the States to make provisions for promotion in the services in favour of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. Article 46 directs the States to promote the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections particularly the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Article 275(1) makes provisions for grants-in-aid from the Consolidated Fund of India for promoting the welfare of the Scheduled Tribes and administration of Scheduled Areas. Reservation of seats for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes in Parliament, state Legislature and in Panchayats is provided under Article 330, Article 332 and Article 243(D) respectively.
Even though the Meiteis in Manipur valley have fulfilled the criteria for being listed in Scheduled Tribes list, they have long been denied these opportunities due to non-inclusion in the list. After Manipur’s merger to Indian Union, Meiteis were given the status of the General Category. In spite of the Meiteis’ belongingness to the Mongoloid stock, a few influential people of that time introduced Meiteis as the descendents of the Aryans to the government of India. People of hill areas were given the status of Scheduled Tribe, while Lois and Yaithibis were categorized as Scheduled Castes. Meiteis have lagged behind other communities of Manipur in matters of appointments to various jobs and promotion to higher ranks due to its being in the general category. Now, Meiteis may also be given the opportunity to preserve and protect its unique culture and tradition under the Constitution. Moreover, in order to being balanced development of the various communities and to narrow down the apparent disparity among communities in Manipur, Meiteis should be accorded Scheduled Tribe status by declaring the whole state of Manipur as hill state. Recognition of Meiteis as a Scheduled Tribe will minimize the apprehension created by onslaught of outsiders from within or without the country. It will help preserve the composite identity and territory of the land.
Recognizing certain religions as religious minority under National Commission of Minorities Act 1992, the Government of India provides assistance in the education of children belonging to these religious minorities. Although National and State commissions have been set up to protect the people of religious communities, Sanamahi religion is yet to be recognized under this category. As Meiteis are adopting all the age-old indigenous traditions, the community can well be categorized as tribal. Meiteis worship Sanamahi deity and follow their age-old traditions during various ceremonies. Even after adopting Hinduism, Meiteis are still following the primitive culture and heritage of the forefathers. Meiteis particularly those following Sanamahi faith are fit to be recognized as Scheduled Tribe under the Constitution of India. Sanamahi faith may also be recognized as a religious minority. Non-inclusion of Meiteis in Scheduled Tribe list is a historical blunder. As an indigenous group, Meiteis need to protect and preserve its age-old customs, traditions and territory under the provisions of Indian Constitution. Right thinking individuals of the state should support the move for recognition of Meiteis as a Scheduled Tribe, even though it is a bit delayed.
Sunday, July 28, 2013
Manipur Tribal Rights Forum Delhi kiphut khia
Manipur a tribal mite ban ah tribal rights leh tribal gamte humbit theih sem ahihna di'n kithukim tak in Manipur Tribal Rights Forum Delhi (MTRFD) kichi phukhiat in om.Manipur Tribal Rights Forum Delhi FORMED
New Delhi, 29 July 2013: A meeting was held at Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) on 28 July, where members of the Manipur tribal communities discussed the demand by the Meitei community for Scheduled Tribe (ST) status.
In response to this ongoing demand, a group of scholars, students, social activists/workers, private employees, and journalists from the Kuki, Naga, Zomi, and Hmar communities of Manipur unanimously formed the Manipur Tribal Rights Forum Delhi (MTRFD) at JNU, New Delhi, on Sunday evening, 28 July 2013. The forum aims to protect the rights, identity, and land of the tribal people in Manipur.
During the panel discussion, members strongly opposed the ST demand by the Scheduled Tribe Demand Committee Manipur (STDCM) and termed it a tactic to undermine the rights of the tribal people.
The office bearers of MTRFD include Dr. Lam Khan Piang (Chairman), Mr. Kokho (Secretary), Dr. David Vumlallian Zou, Dr. Lianboi Vaiphei, Dr. Tennyson, Dr. Alana Golmei, Mr. Lalremlien Neitham, Ms. Ninglun Hanghal, Mr. Thangminlen Kipgen, Mr. Bruce K. Thangkhal, and Mr. Zimik.
Former Member of Parliament Mr. Mani Charanamei also attended the meeting and shared his views on the issue.
The meeting resolved to initiate broader discussions among tribal communities in Delhi on tribal issues in Manipur, with MTRFD set to convene the next gathering.
******************
Delhi ah Manipur Tribal Rights Forum Delhi kiphut khia
~ ZOGAM TODAY
.jpg)
Special Correspondent
Saturday, July 27, 2013
Manipur Photography Club gathers at Deer Park
When “tribe” definition ceases to be anthropological and becomes constitutional
The storm in the tea-cup over the demand from certain sections of the Meitei community for inclusion in the 5th Schedule of the Indian constitution which lists an ever increasing number of recognized tribes in India, is unfortunate for many radically different reasons. Obviously, the tribal status in India is no longer defined by anthropological or sociological parameters, but by the cravings of the incentives accorded to this status.
In this way, the conditions for an ever proliferating number of demands from different communities to be given the tribal status, and equally importantly, the reason for perpetuating this retrogressive social status by those who are already classified in this category, are inherent in the constitution itself. Let there be no dispute about this, what the section of the Meiteis are demanding is not the tribal status but the incentives that come along with it, just as the opposition to the demand by tribal students bodies in the state, is not to another community joining the tribal ranks, but the fear that there will be more competitors of these same incentives and governmental doles.
Both, are pathetic in equal measures, and in fact are the two sides of the same coin. The Meiteis should not be wanting to be tribals, I will give some of my reasons why, and on the other hand, the tribals should have been happy at the prospect of an expanded fraternity. That both parties see it other than this way, is nothing short of a tragedy of a grand story being reduced to a trivial and mundane one. On the wide canvas, the harmatia (or fatal flaw in personality) as the Greeks call it, is that of the incentive structuring of the Indian constitution, and not so much of the much visible dramatis personae of the current issue in Manipur.
I will not go further on whether the tribal status is good or bad for communities which are already listed in the 5th Schedule of the constitution, considering the sensitivity of the issue, but here are some of my reasons why the demand from a section of the Meiteis for tribal status is a bad idea, and I am not saying this out of sentimental reasons, but sound economics. It is a bad idea because the gains can only be short term, and the unseen prices paid for it will be far heavier. I have not done any empirical survey on the matter, so what I say here will be from general observations alone.
Whatever else may be said, the Meitei economy today is one of the most diversified, if not the most diversified in the entire northeast region, including Assam, precisely because its growth has been intrinsic in nature, and not so much a result of pre-fabricated, one-size-fit-all economic models dropped from above. It may not be a monetarily rich economy yet, but have no doubt it would prove the most resilient ultimately. In it is practically every component of a naturally cultured, therefore multifaceted, life’s battle hardened economy. Look at the range of professions the community has nurtured. From cycle repair shops to excellent motorcar workshops, from watch mechanics and TV repair professionals to medical professionals of the highest standards, from traditional doll makers, truck drivers, weavers, to media professionals and academics of repute. Blacksmiths, goldsmiths, gunsmiths, sportsmen, professional dancers, farmers, carpenters, masons, computer hackers… you name it and the Meitei society would have them. Many of these professions were groomed by survival needs, and most began as, and still are extremely lowly paid jobs. Yet they have managed to survive as economic traditions.
This range and reach could not have happened in a completely sponsored economy, which are essentially top heavy and bottom empty. The top is essential no doubt, but ultimately it will be the bottom which will make the difference, once the sponsors retreat.
In fact, most of my criticisms of the Manipur government’s employment, therefore economic policies have been from this standpoint. No government has done much to build the place’s modern economy from this rich traditional foundation, by striving to enrich the environment in which this diversification can thrive and expand, such as by ensuring electricity availability, improving road and internet connectivity, extending better credit facilities to prospective entrepreneurs etc. Instead, today gainful employment has come to mean only garnering government jobs, and we all know government jobs have a very low ceiling, and in fact this ceiling has already been reached. Nonetheless, creating jobs in the government’s parlance continues woefully to be confined to raising more police constabularies etc.
Let those amongst the Meiteis who want the 5th Schedule tribal status do some serious rethinking. Even the OBC status they are now classified into should be treated as a temporary measure. Imagine how hollow and vulnerable an economy which has only government job holders and nothing else would be. There is much wisdom in the saying “Phadi leitana imung keidouneida oiroi” (a household without phadi/towel, can never be complete).
But as I mentioned earlier, if the demand for tribal status by the Meiteis (or at least a section of the community) is bad, the opposition to it from those already classified as tribals is as shameful for it demonstrates how uncivil our “civil society” still is. Indeed, the debate over who or what should constitute the rather ethereal notion of “civil society” gets all the more intriguing in a conflict situation, such as in Manipur. The question is, should “civil society” have a technical definition and be treated as constituting of the occupants of a space earmarked between the State and private vested interests, or other power players, such as the militant challengers to the State’s authority and legitimacy?
While this definition of “civil society” is definitely not sufficient, it has been indeed a convenient one. The trouble however is, when there is a technical definition of “civil society”, it invariably turns into a hotly contested space, and in fact often readily transforms into an extension of the conflicts they are supposed to be arbitrating thus becoming in the process an instrument of the same war, though by other means.
Manipur is familiar with this phenomenon. The “civil society” space has been deeply fissured on sectarian ethnic lines, demonstrations of which are never in short supply. Such wars by other means are fought on practically every issue involving any two or more communities of the state’s multitude of communities. The division is also seen along other broader lines such as between the hill districts and valley districts, between the tribals and non-tribals etc.
It is not uncommon to even hear of self proclaimed human rights organisations, thrown up by mutually antagonistic ethnic communities, speaking two different languages on the same issue. It is as if there is nothing universal about even human rights. How then can the “civil society” be the agent for the much hyped problem solving discourses, is a question much ignored.
The technical ear-marking of a so called “civil society” space leads to another familiar problematic situation. The conflicting parties themselves begin actually to contest for this space by putting up their “civil society” proxies, having realized how powerful these bodies can be in force multiplying their agenda through precisely the “wars by other means”.
The result is a complication of the conflicts themselves. So much has already been written about how even students’ movements have become organs of those behind these conflicts. Some even float their own “civil society” bodies. Must this not be considered a corruption of the popular understanding of “civil society”? A rethink is vital to consider if the definition of civil society must not have some qualitative elements over and above just the quantitative.
A weak State has not helped matter one bit either. Here, legitimate powers that should vest only with it often get wrested away by numerous “civil society” bodies, adding to the general residue of insecurity amongst a larger section of the society. The Weberian notion of legitimate violence is no longer a monopoly of the state, precisely because of its ineptitude and lack of commitment. This legitimacy vests in the hands of so many so called “civil society” bodies, precisely because of the state defaulting. Take the latest case of the hauling up of ice-cream manufacturers for unhygienic factory environment by a students’ body. The vigilant act which would have gained them public legitimacy should have rested solely with the government had it also been as committed to public interest.
Although in a different context, and lacking half the gravity of the powerfully communicated despair in Macbeth’s last word for his queen at the news of her death, in considering Manipur politics, one is reminded of how the great Shakespearean character summarised his wife’s life, “….a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.”
There are many issues of extreme urgency awaiting government attention. Law and order without dispute would rank as number one among all of these. I am not simply referring to the obvious case of insurgency but also again to the manner in which a major portion of what should have remained as sole governmental responsibility, as well as the seal of authority that should have been exclusively the government’s, are being allowed to be wrested away systematically by non-governmental players in the state’s sordid power game.
Or are we witnessing a cruel parody of what Karl Marx called the “withering away of the state”, to give way to a “dictatorship of the proletariat”. The presumption seemed to have been, when the masses are the dictators over their own affairs, rooms for injustice and oppression would be automatically eliminated. The lessons of the atrocities of the French Revolution, which too had justice and equality as its slogans, were surprisingly missed, and VI Lenin’s interpretation of Marxism took cognizance of this problematic area when he stressed on the centrality of the Party of elite thinkers and leaders in any Communist revolution.
In a way he anticipated a basic foundation of modern electoral democracy too, for indeed, democracy is also about a people electing its elite leadership to be in charge of their affairs till so long as they enjoy their confidence as expressed in their periodically renewed electoral mandates. In this way the quality of a democracy is also determined by the capability of an electorate to choose the best amongst its elite. You get the elite you deserve.
In Manipur, the state is withering away, not by any grand Marxian design, but precisely for the abject lack of a will or imagination to come up with a design. For our elected elite, the needs for accountability or good governance are secondary to their personal agenda centred around the competition for the spoils and clout of office.
A rule of the masses has thereby been unleashed, leading to a mad contest for the powers of governance amongst various “civil society” organisations. Today many of these mushrooming power centres have naturally filled in where the government is absent and have even assumed the judicial powers of summons, inquisitions and trials, executive powers of levying taxes, excise duties and even to mete out summary punishments.
They legislate too through diktats and decrees. And yet the government continues to pretend there is nothing seriously wrong and that the law and order situation has improved. Time for all, most pertinently the government, to wake up.
Source:kanglaonline.com
ATSUM hits back to ST Demand Committe Manipur & Prime Minister
Friday, July 26, 2013
UTLA clarifies: Terminates its former GS
Featured Post
KHRC Condemns CM's Churachandpur Helicopter Visit
Lamka, July 4, 2026: The Kuki Human Rights Council (KHRC) has strongly condemned the Government of India for facilitating Manipur Chief Min...
Recent Posts
-
--- Viewers discretion is advised ---
-
March 14, 2025: A statement by 𝐈𝐧𝐝𝐢𝐚 𝐅𝐨𝐫 𝐌𝐲𝐚𝐧𝐦𝐚𝐫 has highlighted the worsening plight of Myanmar refugees in India, who face ...
-
THE ZOMIS are one of the branches of Mongolian stock allied to the Tibetan Burmans and whose stories dates back to 2,000 BC. These people ...



.jpg)














.jpg)


.jpg)
.jpg)
